IDENTIFYING YOU CHARACTERS

Wed, Aug 4 2010 03:26pm IST 1
BobAird
BobAird
92 Posts
Hello everyone,

Just looking for some advice regarding when to identify my character as 'Jack' or he/him? Then if 'Jill' turns up when do I refer to her as 'Jill' or as she/her.

I write in 3rd person narrative and keep it subjective to one character at a time. I have no problem with saying, 'Jack and Jill went up the hill. He fetched a pail of water. She watched, not offering any help. On coming back down, (Jill/she?) stuck out a foot and tripped (Jack/him?).'

What's the golden rule for getting it right?

Bob
Wed, Aug 4 2010 03:39pm IST 2
Weens
Weens
993 Posts
I think the best way to handle this is, is it clear who is speaking/doing etc. If it is not clear, then a name is required. That's what I try to do. Ask someone to read any passage you are struggling with, and ask them if it is clear who is speaking. Our main objective is to make sure the reader gets it. There may be a technical 'rule' for this, but that's the way I would handle it.
Wed, Aug 4 2010 03:57pm IST 3
EmmaD
EmmaD
1801 Posts
If you've only got two people in the scene and they're different sexes, you really don't need to give their names very often, if at all. It gets trickier when there are more, and there isn't a rule, really, just instinct, so it's somewhere where your beta/trusted readers are very useful, to tell you when they got confused, or felt hit over the head with names.

And don't forget the useful rule of thumb that when it comes to identifying lines of dialogue, in a two-hander you should make it clear who's speaking (by either a linked action, or a speech tag) every five lines...

Emma
Thu, Aug 5 2010 02:16am IST 4
Babblefish
Babblefish
846 Posts

Every five line aye? .... useful, I'd never thought about a rule of thumb for that, I'll have to look into that in my stories whenever the dialouge gets confusing.

Thu, Aug 5 2010 08:50am IST 5
BobAird
BobAird
92 Posts
Weens/EmmaD

Thank you for the input. You've given me some confidence as I think I've been doing it right. I have some short and snappy dialogue sections in my book but I seem to have inserted a linked action or a speech tag within every five lines. I certainly be using the 'every five line' rule from now on. I do like rules!

Bob

Please login or sign up to post on this network.
Click here to sign up.