| Mon, Jan 23 2012 01:48pm GMT 1 |

Alanboy
434 Posts
|
"Their Headquarters are here"
Is this correct? Surely Headquarters is singular?
I have just heard this on Nat. Geographic. Perhaps it's an American
convention. Does anyone know?
Manchester City scores first. So, a football club is
singular.
Leeds loses. Okay, but it doesn't sound right.
Do I need Skunk and Right?
|
|
| Mon, Jan 23 2012 03:59pm GMT 2 |

Captain Morgan
149 Posts
|
Interestingly, Yanks use ‘is’ for singular more often than we
do…comes down to context and, at times, preference. Me, I’d never
say, ‘Manchester city is a good team.’ Just sounds so wrong, even
if it’s not.
|
|
| Mon, Jan 23 2012 04:07pm GMT 3 |

EmmaD
1997 Posts
|
UK style is that it depends whether a noun like "Headquarters" is
being used in the sense of a group of people, or a unit.
So:
Headquarters are having a meeting.
Headquarters is being painted.
Headquarters is moving to Salford and it'll be a much nicer
place
Headquarters are moving to Salford and they're very pleased about
it.
US tends to be more doctrinaire, and insist that a noun like that
is singular, so I'm interested that Nat Geog don't - on the other
hand, I see why in that sentence, if the focus is on several people
(animals?)
UK - you could write "The crowd are scattering in all directions"
whereas many US editors would insist that it's "The crowd is
scattering in all directions", even when the singular object is
actually breaking up into its plural parts...
|
|
| Tue, Jan 24 2012 01:36am GMT 4 |

Alanboy
434 Posts
|
I instinctively say 'Manchester City beat Manchester United'
because it is the collective group of players who do the beating,
not a football club in its totality. Okay, I know it is not
technically correct. The spoken word often isn't, but it's a
different matter when you're trying to please doctrinaire editors
with a MS.
Thank you, Emma, for clarifying. I am English, and will stick to
English, not American English.
However, in your last example, I would use "The crowd is scattering
..." without thinking.
If you say "The crowd are scattering ..." it sounds as though crowd
should be plural. Hence "The crowds are scattering ..."
I see it as a single unit that is scattering. We're not talking
about individuals.
So, "The police unit in the crowd is scattering" but "The police in
the crowd are scattering"
I don't like American English - "Where is he at?" Yuk, Ugh,
Spit.
"He's gotten a fire cerificate." Vomit, puke.
But, in the crowd case, they have a point.
|
|
| Tue, Apr 3 2012 09:08pm IST 5 |

MalcolmSm1th
2 Posts
|
The crowd is a lump of people so 'is' for me.
The Headquarters is another lump, so an 'is' vote frome me. I would
say "Their Headquarters is here."
- Malc
|
|
| Tue, Apr 17 2012 07:14pm IST 6 |

curlykats
579 Posts
|
I agree that Leeds loses doesn't sound right but for different
reasons! I would say 'the crowd is...'. When I'm writing medical
articles, we are very correct and write 'data were presented...'
which is one that people commonly get wrong.
|
|