The Curse of Overwriting.

Published by: CJ on 13th Feb 2010 | View all blogs by CJ

"I fear my enthusiasm flags when real work is demanded of me" H.P Lovecraft, 1890 - 1937

*Stands up*

My name is Ely, and I overwrite.

From the tiniest shimmer of the dust mote that floats elegantly down from an incandescent heaven to the overpowering maelstrom of the storm that rages with a power that defies all overhead, I overwrite. Adjectives, adverbs, overextended metaphors, overblown synonyms that have been sought desperately for in my well-thumbed thesaurus are all my friends; dear, dear friends I have spent a lifetime collecting, devising, enjoying.

But, alas, unlike my idols Lovecraft, Poe and Stoker, we do not live in a time where a love of language is de rigueur. To write because you love words is not enough. For fear of being rather melodramatic, I would describe myself as a bit of a shadow out of time  (nudge nudge, wink wink); an anachronism who needs to let go of these archaic mentors and begin to live in the literary now.

But how to cut those ties? To cut loose that which brings fire to your belly? To prune, yet feel you are not losing that which defines and inflames  you?

That, I do not know. It escapes me, cantering into the depths of the maelstrom above with a gleeful kick of its heels, defying me, challenging me: come and find me, but do it with less reliance on adverbial phrases and passive passages beginning with words that end in 'ing'.

Time to put the thesaurus back onto the shelf, methinks...

 

Comments

12 Comments

  • Wrenstales
    by Wrenstales 2 years ago
    Everyone, feels like they have overwriten and ythe need to use a thesaurus. However the more you write, the more the story or poem comes out of you.
    I did have the same problem with ING, but I ry to avoid it. I just write , edit and red edit and read and write and then ask someone to crit it. Many crits are good and some can be a bit awfull, but those crits who are awfull only crit like that because they have expereince, but that should not put you off. I would suggest to you to read everyones crit, good and bads, weigh them up and decide for yourself where you can improve.
  • kd
    by kd 2 years ago
    welcome to the club my dear:) I wish I had some advice but I'm just starting to figure my way out from under my overwritten prose.
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    I know you're a Lovecraft fan, Mistress Elysia, but what about Clark Ashton Smith? I loved that guy's stuff and nobody could ever accuse him of brevity. Remember the opening section from 'The Maze of Maal Dweb'? I'll quote it here in its entiriety to the unitiated. Keep in mind that this is the edited version - C.A.S. had published an earlier (more long-winded) version which he preferred.


    By the light of the four small waning moons of Xiccarph, Tiglari had crossed that bottomless swamp wherein no reptile dwelt and no dragon descended; but where the pitch-black ooze was alive with incessant heavings. He had not cared to use the high causey of corundum that spanned the fen, and had threaded his way with much peril from isle to sedgy isle that shuddered gelatinously beneath him. When he reached the solid shore and the shelter of the palm-tall rushes, he did not approach the porphyry stairs that wound skyward through giddy chasms and along glassy scarps to the house of Maal Dweb. The causey and the stairs were guarded by the silent, colossal automatons of Maal Dweb, whose arms ended in long crescent blades of tempered steel which were raised in implacable scything against any who came thither without their master's permission.

    Tiglari's naked body was smeared with the juice of a plant repugnant to all the fauna of Xiccarph. By virtue of this he hoped to pass unharmed the ferocious ape-like creatures that roamed at will through the tyrant's cliff-hung gardens. He carried a coil of woven root-fibre, strong and light, and weighted with a brazen ball, for use in climbing the mesa. At his side, in a sheath of chimera-skin, he wore a needle-sharp knife that had been dipped in the poison of winged vipers.'

    Pretty cool, huh?
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    Actually I'm wondering now if this IS the unedited version....
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    No wait, here's an excerpt from the original, unrevised version, which C.A.S. self-published. Which do you think is better? CAS preferred the original, but I actually think the edited version is an improvement.

    With no other light than that of the four diminutive moons of Xiccarph, each in a different phase but all decrescent, Tiglari had crossed the bottomless swamp of Soorm, wherein no reptile dwelt & no dragon descended -- but where the pitch-black ooze was alive with continual heavings & writhings. He had carefully avoided the high causey of white corundum that spanned the fen, & had threaded his way with infinite peril from isle to sedgy isle that shuddered gelatinously beneath him. When he reached the solid shore & the shelter of the palm-tall rushes, he was equally careful to avoid the pale porphyry stairs that wound heavenward through dizzy nadir-cleaving chasms & along glassy scarps to the ever-mysterious & terrible house of Maal Dweb. The causey & the stairs were guarded by those that he did not wish to meet: the silent, colossal iron servitors of Maal Dweb, whose arms ended in long crescent blades of tempered steel which were raised in implacable scything against any who came thither without their master's permission.
  • CJ
    by CJ 2 years ago
    Ahhhhhh, Clark Ashton Smith - yes, I have The Book of Eibon (in it's full, bonkers glory) upstairs. Bless him - he certainly loved his words! Y'see... even I can see that this is so overwritten it borders on the insane. Maybe there was a reason we decided to flee in the opposite direction... XD

    I'm with you - the edited version is better. It is more concise (as far as CAS can be concise, of course...) and I found that after a few lines, my eye started to wander... not a good sign!

    Have you read any Arthur Machen? He's the only man I've read that can string together three semi colons (and not be connected in any way with a list) in one description. It's fantastic! (I'll see if I can find it - it's in the story about the Angel of the Mons (The Terror?).

    What I do find amusing is these wonderfully erudite men invariable gave their tales such crap names...
  • CJ
    by CJ 2 years ago
    kd - if you do find a magic bullet for it, would you share?! ^_^
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    I really like Arthur Machen as well. Funnily enough I read an early work of his only recently. It was about some guy who becomes fascinated by a roman fortress near him. You know how Machen is very good at building up atmosphere, even if the actual explanation is a bit pants? Well I kept waiting for the horror bit to kick in, only it never did. Guy is fascinated by Roman fortress. Guy climbs hill, explores fortress, falls asleep, wakes up, comes back down again and has shit life. The end.

    Seemingly it was written before Machen became known primarily as a horror writer. I never could figure out what the roman fortress was mean to signify, if anything.
  • CJ
    by CJ 2 years ago
    I haven't read that one - it sounds fantastic, though (in a kind of ironic way...). I thiink a lot of horror writers suffer from 'excellent build up, pants ending' - I don't think I ever got over the fact that It in Stephen King's It (well, duh... heh heh) was, in actuality, a big spider. I mean, come on... at least Lovecraft *tried* to make his weird monsters actually be weird (if a bit baffling. The Elder Things that all kind of resemble rugose coral? Yeah, that was odd...). Thinking about it, I don't know if I've actually read a modern horror book that didn't deflate a bit during the denouement. They either go a bit flat (aforementioned It, Cabal) or go totally and utterly bonkers-mental (The Spear. Jesus, that book lost it in the most amusingly insane way ever...). Saying that, though, there is a terrible weight of responsibility upon the horror writer - you've taken your reader up to this point, where their minds are racing and they think they're going to be shown the secrets of a hidden universe... oh, crap. What scares people? Oh, I know!! SPIDERS!!!

    Always with the spiders...
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    I never read 'It' but I enjoyed the film. If you look really closely, the spider's antennae end in a pair of human hands - I'm guessing this was to plug some plot holes in the storyline, like when the evil clown actually grabbed somebody by the hand. He couldn't do that if he was just a gigantic spider, could he?

    Still can't figure out how something that size could lurk down in the town drains. A bit like 'Godzilla' where we're expected to believe some giant dinosaur can terrorise New York, then hide down in the subway. Hmmm.....
  • Wrathnar the Unreasonable
    Well, spiders scare me ( shudder ). Have you read Lord Dunsany? He is pretty much the Overlord of Overwriting. I've posted a thing on Fantasy/SF group that's relevant to this topic, I even referred to your work, Elysia, please forgive me!

    I sometimes struggle with under-writing; I get over-excited and rush, not taking the time to fill in detail, then have to go back and rewrite. Character engagement seems to be my main weakness. More thoughts and feelings needed, rather than just telling what the character is doing and saying. It's something I need to work on.
  • Aonghus Fallon
    by Aonghus Fallon 2 years ago
    I read 'The King of Elfland's Daughter' years ago, and 'The Curse of the Bogwoman' along with some of his stories. I'd say 'The King of Elfland's Daughter' is just as prosy as 'The Maze of Maal Dwebb' but Dunsay was very prolific and tended to adopt different styles depending on the content.

    You mentioned tending to skip over what the characters are thinking and saying. Have you read Dashell Hammett? Now there was a guy who believed in being concise. In 'The Maltese Falcon' (not his best work, I reckon, but pretty good all the same) the characters are all described from the outside, like you're watching a movie - you never know what's going on inside the central character's head (Sam Spade) - and it works very well indeed.
Please login or sign up to post on this network.
Click here to sign up now.

Subscribe

Getting Published


Twitter

Visitor counter



Literature


 

Blog Roll Centre

Books

Blog Hints

Blog Directory