Unsuccessful competition entry
I'd really appreciate some feedback on this short story - I think I
know where some of its problems lie (like the over-complex
sentences) but have probably missed loads. It was for the Theakston
thing where they gave you the first line, it's about 2000 words.
Job done “In my experience, those who beg for mercy seldom deserve
it.” So used to say “The Guv’nor” when he was in one of his more
self-rationalising moods. Perhaps it made his job – which he never
really seemed to enjoy even at the best of times – bearable. He was
saying it now. I must have looked sceptical though, because he
scratched his nose the way he always did when he was feeling
threatened. “And believe me, he’ll beg. What’s wrong with you,
Shane?” he grumbled. “You wanted to join the firm. You wanted to
prove yourself.” “I just don’t see the connection,” I said. “Surely
there must be plenty of occasions where you can’t equate fear with
guilt?” “Self-righteous little prig”, he responded. I think he said
“prig”. “Well,” I began. “Just do it,” he said, “or I’ll get
someone else to.” “Okay, okay,” I said. “How do you want it done?”
“It’s a Cat. C.” Category C. That meant no witnesses, but no need
to go to any lengths to hide the results either. “Okay,” I said
again. “When?” “Tonight, any time up until six tomorrow morning.”
It was company policy not to give you too much warning on jobs like
these. They had some theory about too much thinking time meaning
too much scope for over-complication and mistakes. “At his home,
you said. Or you were saying, just before you trotted out the
begging for mercy line.” He looked crossly at me. “At his home. 27
Laurel Avenue. The photos are in the file. Don’t take them with
you.” This was an unkind and unnecessary reference to the time back
when I was a very nervous beginner and I had left an envelope of
photos, together with a credit card receipt from a nearby petrol
station, on the kitchen counter at the target’s home. I had had to
go back and get them, and although I managed to do this perfectly
successfully, I knew that the original incident would never be
forgotten. “I won’t.” I went upstairs and took the file out of the
drawer. In a colour-coded document wallet (yellow for Category C) I
found the photos of the locus, the target and, rather to my dismay,
of a large Rottweiler with a malignant expression. The animal was
lying on a sofa, apparently watching television, rather than being
securely chained up by its neck somewhere in the back garden. There
were also plan sketches of the house and yard, a timetable of the
target’s activities over the last two weeks, and a note to the
effect that this was for a very good client. The recce team had
done their usual thorough job. The Guv’nor was always boasting
about how good they were, and how he had personally headhunted them
all – literally, in fact, in the case of an ex-mercenary called
Knut. According to the activity timetable, the target’s daily
routine was gratifyingly consistent. His alarm went off at 7
a.m.,he lay in bed listening to Radio 1 until half-past, then he
got up,showered, went downstairs, persuaded the Rottweiler to get
off the sofa and go outside, breakfasted on cornflakes and tea,
brought the dog back inside, and left the house to walk to the
station to catch the 8.22 to Paddington. He returned on the 17.10
from Paddington, let the dog out, changed into jogging gear and set
off round the block, this took him twenty minutes. Once back inside
he poured himself a small vodka, made himself some toast, let the
dog back in and fed it, changed from his jogging gear into jeans
and except on Fridays, set off for the Turnpike. On Fridays he went
to Purple People Eaters, a club on Lower Canal Street. He returned
from the pub at 11.05, and from the club at 12.05. The dog appeared
to sleep soundly through his homecomings, as it never raised even
its head from the sofa. Ideally, since it was Friday, leaving the
club would be the optimum time, but the client had stated “at his
home”. This could be for a number of reasons, the most likely being
that there would be a certain delay before the deed was discovered.
Clients often needed a bit of breathing space just to come to terms
with what had actually happened before the news got out. And
although this particular client normally had no such sensitivities,
all his previous instructions had been connected with his
businesses whereas this one was rather more personal. So bearing in
mind that the dog – and evil-looking as it was, I was starting to
feel a bit sorry for it – was only outside the house for a short
period in the morning and again in the evening, I picked up the
photos again. I could see that I only had two possible courses of
action, break in, or be invited in. It was too late for the
dog-free period for this morning, so that really only left the
dog-free period this evening. But it was August, so breaking-in
unseen was not much of a possibility. The side and front windows
were clearly visible from the street, and by the neighbours, and
the back windows were in Rottweiler territory. That left being
invited in. There were a few choices here, I thought. Meter reader,
courier, JW? Then I had a sudden inspiration: RSPCA Inspector.
“There’s been a very serious complaint”, I could say, about a dog
being starved in the back yard, someone had seen a very thin
Rottweiler at the side gate on a number of occasions. The target
would, with perfect justification, be sufficiently indignant not to
look too closely at my “credentials” and would insist on dragging
me all the way through the house to where the overfed twelve-stone
monster would be slouched against the back door waiting to come
back inside for its daily twenty-three hour nap on the sofa. There
he would point out to me that there was no possible way that this
creature could be described as either “starved” or “very thin”.
Obviously we would not get as far as the back door. I unlocked our
props cupboard and found a cap which with a little adjustment would
easily pass for an RSPCA one. Sitting it on the desk, I went
on-line to their homepage and studied photos of the rest of their
get-up. Easy, I said to myself. The cap, sat on my totally
undistinguished head, would not cause any unwanted second glances.
I rang the intercom to the garage where Jose would be working on
one of the cars. Or pretending to work on one of the cars. “Yes?”
the response was not welcoming. I don’t know why the Guv’nor kept
him on, but he does tend to wink and tap his nose a lot. “Hi Jose,
it’s Shane. I’ll need the little van this afternoon.” “Yeah.” I
took that as meaning I could have it. The weapon needed a little
more thought. I may not be all that fastidious in my day to day
life but I don’t like blood. I mean I really don’t like blood. Mine
or anyone else’s. I’m not crazy about noise either. Or physical
contact with the target. My options, as usual, were getting fewer
and, as usual, I’d have to compromise. I practised my lines as I
drove back to target’s house, and by the time I was parking a
couple of doors away from his front gate I felt I was word-perfect
and very convincing. I knocked on the door. Footsteps, then the
door opened. “Yes?” Halfway into my “very thin dog” recital he
suddenly said: “Wait here” and shut the door in my face. Shortly
afterwards he reappeared, with the hulking great brute of a dog on
a lead. “Take it. It’s all yours. The wife left it with me when she
buggered off. Its name’s Fred.” He handed me the lead and slammed
the door. Fred glared at me and I glared back. That was not
supposed to happen. Temporarily defeated, I took Fred back to the
van and tried to persuade him to get into the back of it. He
refused. I had to offer him the passenger seat and he condescended
to climb in, although when I got into the driver seat he stretched
out and rested about half a ton of slobbering head on my lap. Well,
I consoled myself, at least the target’s house was now dog-free.
There was nothing to stop me sneaking round the back after dark and
carrying out my assignment. I drove unsteadily off, nearly stalling
twice as my left leg was going numb from the weight of the dog’s
head and I was finding it hard to work the clutch. I began to
realise that now I was lumbered with this dog, the fact that I had
him would be more than a little incriminating. I was just going to
have to turn him loose somewhere, and make sure no-one saw me doing
it. I wasn’t even sure how I was going to get him out of the van. I
managed to get back to the office and drove into the yard. As I
suspected, Fred was reluctant to move, so I left him there. I made
sure that the windows were down a little bit to let the air in –
and to be honest, he could have done with a bath – and also so that
he would not get too hot. Half past ten would be a good time. It
would be getting dark by then, and although the target always left
the lamp on top of the television switched on and I would have
enough light to see what I was doing, I would still have enough
cover to break in unseen. Fred and I set off back to Laurel Street.
I parked a couple of streets away, not on the target’s route home
from the club, behind a bush which I had calculated would conceal
me from the two CCTV systems I had noted on neighbouring
properties. I left the van and went quickly back round the block,
down the drive and over the locked side gate. Once around the back
of the house, it was a very simple matter to break in through the
kitchen window. This took me into a big open plan area with the
kitchen on one side and the sofa and television on the other, so I
went into the living room part and settled down to wait. The target
arrived home unexpectedly early, well before midnight. I thought
for one horrible moment that he had not returned alone, but the
conversation he was having when he came in his front door was on
his mobile. “No, he’s gone. I had him put down. You’ll never see
him again. Sweetheart.” The last word was snarled rather than
spoken. I prepared myself as he came down the hallway into the
kitchen, and from behind him, I slipped the hood over his head and
the garrotte around his neck. “Don’t move”, I warned, “Just relax
and nothing will happen.” He struggled a bit and I tightened the
garrotte a couple of notches. He stopped struggling and started to
shake. “Keep your hands by your sides.” It’s not easy to keep your
hands by your sides when someone is trying to throttle you, but he
was frightened enough to manage it. “Who are you? What do you
want?” “No talking,” I said. “Okay, you’re going to stand perfectly
still and listen.” His knees buckled slightly but the pressure of
the garrotte made him stand up again. He started to sob. “Please
don’t hurt me,” he whimpered, “Do you want money? You can have my
cashcards. And pincodes.” ‘I don’t want money,’ I said, ‘The client
pays well. And I said don’t talk, just listen. And I’ll kill you if
you move.” I let him think about that for a few moments. “What my
client wants,” I explained, “is for you to suffer pain and fear and
humiliation. It’s a sort of a revenge thing.” He gulped, but didn’t
say anything. I released the garrotte slightly. I didn’t want him
passing out just yet. Yes, I know, the longer you spend not killing
someone, the less you are likely actually to do it. Sort of
Stockholm Syndrome in reverse. But the target needed to know why.
That had been part of our instructions. “Your father-in-law – soon
to be ex-father-in-law I suppose that is now – doesn’t seem to like
you very much,” I began. “He seems to think, now how did he put it?
– that you are a dishonest, two-timing, cheating, snivelling little
rat. And that’s the censored version, of course.” The target
sobbed. “No, no, that’s not true. Please!” “He also thinks you
should be punished.” “No, no, please, I haven’t done anything, I
swear on my mother’s life, I’ve never done anything wrong, I’ve
never hurt anyone, I’ve always done the right thing, I was a good
husband, please, why are you doing this? My father-in-law’s a
bully, he never liked me, he –” This self-pity was interrupted by a
commotion at the front door and then Fred came padding down the
hall. He leapt lovingly at the target, and we both crashed to the
floor, which Fred apparently thought was a nice new game. He
grabbed my arm and playfully chewed at it, causing me to lose my
grip on the garrotte. I stood up, backing away and examining my
arm, and Fred, unfitness winning out over excitement, wagged his
massive backend and hauled himself onto the sofa. The target was
still lying on the floor. He was completely motionless, which
surprised me, too terrified to move, I decided. I knelt beside him
to reattach the garrotte and he gave a sudden start, then his head
lolled back and he was motionless once more. That was when I
noticed the blood seeping though the hood onto the cream hearth
rug. I nudged his foot. Nothing. I gently eased the hood off, and
looked at the dead eyes, and the crumpled temple where his head had
hit the edge of the hearth. I sat back on my heels, holding the
hood away from me. I glanced around the kitchen, looking for a
carrier bag, I could not leave it there, but I didn’t want blood on
my clothes either. There was one of those cloth bag tidy things
near the fridge, I took out a Tesco bag and put the hood inside it.
Fred was still lying on the sofa, watching me. Perhaps he thought I
might be going to feed him. “Sorry Fred,” I said, “but I’ll leave
the back door open for you.” I walked back down the hallway to the
front door which Fred had managed to push open. The target had been
so engrossed in his telephone conversation when he came in that he
had not closed the door properly, nothing appeared to be damaged,
and the door closed and locked itself when I pulled it towards me.
The street was very quiet, and I walked as casually as I could back
to the van. It was easy to see how Fred had got out, as the
passenger window was lyingin pieces on the side of the road. God
only knew how many fingerprints – or nose marks – might be found on
those pieces of glass, so I picked them all up before I drove home.
The job was done. That was all my report and invoice needed to say.


12 Comments
All I've got is that I liked it, but I wanted more up front intrigue. There is intrigue there, but in a short story I prefer to be clobbered by it repeatedly. Obviously, others will feel differently, and I hope you don't lose sight of the fact that I enjoyed reading it.
i don't mean to be rude, kate, but i'd have to be utterly bored, directionless and unmotivated to wade through such a long paragraph; and if you want to succeed in comps or get published, you must present your stuff in a reader-friendly way.
i didn't read any of what you wrote, but i'd give this same advice to anyone
I promise to read this tomorrow, if I get a moment.
"... and left the house to walk to the station to catch the 8.22 to Paddington. He returned on the 17.10 from Paddington [you don't need to repeat Paddington], let the dog out, changed into jogging gear and set off round the block, this took him twenty minutes [that should have been a new sentence btw]. Once back inside he poured himself a small vodka, made himself [better not to repeat himself] some toast."
You don't really need to say "he left the house" to walk to the station - he could hardly walk there without leaving the house. Then, do you really need, "he walked to the station"? Couldn't we assume that, since he caught the train? That passage could be as succinct as:
"Each day he caught the 8:22 to Paddington and returned on the 17:10. He let the dog out, changed and jogged round the block for twenty minutes before returning for a small vodka and toast."
Quite often 'less' is 'more'. You'll probably see other places where you could tighten up a little on your prose. Don't let too many words detract from the power of the story. Write on, Kate.
I think the biggest hurdle you need to look at was writing in the first person. That led you to emphasise TELLING what happened instead of SHOWING your characters emotions towards what happened.
Steve - will remember to start with a bang rather than a meandering - you are right!
Caf - thank you for persevering!
Mark - even I baulked at re-reading the breakless passage, but I just couldn't work out how to preserve my formatting. I use a Mac so wonder if this makes any difference?
Tony - thanks for your detailed and very helpful comments. You are absolutely right and this is one of those things it's hard for me to do - kill my words - even when I know I should. You have given me a real boost by showing me that my ideas are not unsalvageable.
Stephenterry - commiserations! and thank you for your insights. I really struggle to write in third person but will try harder to master it. Would you be willing to post your entry?
I m really pleased I grasped the nettle and posted this - even if the formatting didn't work - and humbledly grateful to everyone who struggled through it and responded.
The dog is central to the story because it determines when the property can be entered, provides a pretext for entering the property and an insight into the victim's "cruelty" to his wife (telling her it's been put down), and ultimately causes the victim's death by knocking him over. And then because it is only a dog it just goes back to sleep as if nothing has happened, leaving the protagonist to claim the hit.
Click here to sign up now.